Matthew Schaefer scored his first career NHL hat trick on Tuesday night, November 17, 2026, as the New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena. FINAL: New York Islanders 5, Columbus Blue Jackets 1. The 19-year-old defenseman from Hamilton, Ontario, became only the third teenage defenseman in NHL history to score three goals in a game, and the first in 43 years.
Matthew Schaefer Hat Trick Joins A List Unchanged Since 1983
The history is the story. Long Island Hockey Insider reported that Schaefer is only the third teenage defenseman in NHL history with a hat trick, joining Phil Housley on January 23, 1983, and Hannu Virta on March 19, 1983. Both men did it as Buffalo Sabres rookies two months apart: Housley scored all three of his goals on the power play against Winnipeg at 18 years old, and Virta followed at 19, three days before his 20th birthday. No teenage defenseman had done it since, in more than four decades of hockey played by some of the best young blueliners the game has produced.
Join The iimiTV Letter
Enter your email and we will send you a confirmation link. Click it and your first edition lands on Friday.
The position itself explains the wait. Hat tricks by defensemen are rare at any age, and the NHL’s own recap of Simon Nemec’s hat trick in November 2025 noted that in the previous 30 years the only defensemen aged 21 or younger to record one were P.K. Subban, Rasmus Ristolainen and Nemec himself. Schaefer has now done it at 19, in his second NHL season, a year after winning the Calder Trophy as the league’s top rookie. Columbus, of all teams, has seen this movie before: on November 2, 2025, in this same building, an 18-year-old Schaefer scored twice against the Blue Jackets to become the youngest defenseman in NHL history with a multi-goal game, passing Bobby Orr. “We really grinded them out there,” Schaefer said that night, in the NHL’s recap of that game. “It’s fun hockey to play and fun hockey to watch too.” Simon Holmstrom added then: “It’s been fun to watch, to say the least.” A year later, against the same opponent, Schaefer went one goal better.
Three Schaefer Goals Finish A Game Columbus Briefly Threatened
New York built its lead in layers. Anthony Duclair opened the scoring on the power play at 19:02 of the first period, from Mathew Barzal and Tony DeAngelo, and Schaefer made it 2-0 with an unassisted goal at 1:34 of the second, a sniper’s finish for his seventh goal of the season. Ilya Sorokin held Columbus scoreless through two periods, and the Islanders outshot the Blue Jackets 14-11 and 14-10 across the first two frames, as the Columbus game recap recorded. Zach Werenski cut the lead to 2-1 at 1:12 of the third period, from Kent Johnson and Luca Del Bel Belluz, and for a few minutes the game was live again.
Schaefer closed it himself. His second goal, a rebound finish at 7:01 of the third from Ryan Pulock and Duclair, survived a Columbus challenge for goaltender interference and restored the two-goal lead at 3-1. DeAngelo scored just under three minutes after the ensuing power play expired, from Barzal and Matias Maccelli, to make it 4-1, and with Cam Talbot pulled, Schaefer completed the hat trick into the empty net at 16:08, from Holmstrom and Bo Horvat. The official box score line tells the size of his night: three goals on nine shots, a plus-2 rating and 23:23 of ice time, with first star honours. Sorokin made 28 saves on 29 shots, Talbot stopped 36 of the 40 he faced before the empty-net goal, and the Islanders, who took no penalties all night, outshot Columbus 41-29. Sportsnet’s highlight package shows all three goals.
One Night, Three More Schaefer Lists Climbed
The hat trick moved Schaefer up several lists at once. His third goal was the 32nd of his NHL career, tying Bryan Trottier for the most goals by a teenager in Islanders history: the Islanders’ own statistical notes, The Skinny, listed Trottier at 32 and Schaefer at 29 before Tuesday’s game. His three points took him to 83 for his career, one behind Rasmus Dahlin’s 84 for second place among teenage defensemen all time, with Housley’s 132 still the standard. It was also his fourth career three-point game, tying Al Iafrate for third among teenage defensemen behind Housley (10) and Ray Bourque (6), per the NHL Morning Skate’s count entering this week. Schaefer now has nine goals this season, tied with Horvat and Holmstrom for the Islanders team lead, from the blue line, and a point in six straight games. Five days earlier in Los Angeles he had become the youngest defenseman in NHL history to reach 100 career games, at 19 years and 68 days.
For Columbus, the loss was a fifth straight, dropping the Blue Jackets to 7-12-0 in the third game they have played without head coach Rick Bowness, who is away for medical testing; their road trip continues Thursday in Chicago. The Islanders, 10-6-4 with three straight wins and points in five straight, go the other way: Thursday at Winnipeg, then Saturday at Detroit. Schaefer will play this entire season as a teenager, which means the lists he climbed on Tuesday are lists he can keep climbing until September.








