The Toronto Blue Jays are in the final conversation for the biggest free agent pitcher on the market. Toronto met with two time Cy Young Award winner Tarik Skubal and agent Scott Boras this week, the meeting was reported to have gone really well, and ESPN’s Buster Olney reported on Wednesday, November 18 that the expectation of some involved is that the bidding will pit the Mets against the Blue Jays in the end. Skubal is unsigned, no offer has been confirmed, and this is a race, not a signing. But the shape of the finish now has Toronto in it.
The meeting schedule explains how fast this market is moving. MLB Trade Rumors reported that Skubal sat down with the Mets first, in the first of six meetings planned for this week, with the Dodgers, Padres and Blue Jays among the clubs getting in person time with Skubal and the Boras Corporation. ESPN’s Jeff Passan reported that Skubal met the Dodgers and the Blue Jays on Tuesday, after the Monday meeting with the Mets, and that the Padres meeting was still to come this week.
Join The iimiTV Letter
Enter your email and we will send you a confirmation link. Click it and your first edition lands on Friday.
Do not discount the Blue Jays. They are flush with cash and prepared to spend it.
That was Passan’s warning in his Wednesday free agency rundown, as summarized in the day’s reporting. Passan also reported that the Mets left their meeting impressed, reinforcing their status as favorites, while cautioning that calling this a one team race does not reflect the reality of Skubal’s market.
Why Toronto Fits The Ace And The Moment
Jim Bowden added the Toronto detail that matters most. Speaking on the JD Bunkis podcast, Bowden said the Blue Jays had a really good meeting with Skubal and Boras, and that the club would really love to team him with Dylan Cease at the top of the rotation. Bowden also said his understanding is that the Boras Corporation wants to get this deal done before December 1, and that he was told the meeting went really well.
That December 1 date is not a soft target. The collective bargaining agreement expires on December 1 and a lockout is expected, which gives every party a hard reason to finish early. Skubal also turns 30 on Friday, and he is selling the rarest asset in the sport: a left handed ace in his prime, coming off a season with a 2.72 earned run average and 186 strikeouts in 26 starts. Reporting on the Olney update noted Skubal met the Mets on Monday and the Dodgers and Blue Jays on Tuesday, with the Padres expected later in the week, and that his camp is seeking a long term contract rather than a short term, high salary deal.
The Price And The Precedent
The money will be historic if the reporting holds. Skubal and Boras have told teams he is not interested in a short term deal, with the reported floor for a long term contract past $325 million, and Passan’s reporting pointed to an eventual deal that would be the largest ever for a pitcher. That preference complicates the Dodgers, who are reported to prefer fewer years at a higher annual value, and it plays directly into the hands of a club willing to commit long term.
Toronto has already run this exact play with this exact agency. Last winter, early meetings between the Blue Jays, Dylan Cease and Boras led to a seven year, $210 million contract in late November. The precedent does not guarantee a repeat, and it should not be reported as one. It does show that Toronto knows how these Boras negotiations move, that the club has been willing to close early rather than drift into December, and that a Skubal and Cease top two is a plan the front office has already modelled, not a fantasy drawn up this week.
What Happens If Toronto Misses
The Blue Jays are not betting the whole winter on one left hander. Reporting this week has also connected Toronto to trade and free agent alternatives across the infield and the rotation, and one reported pivot if Skubal signs elsewhere is free agent starter Michael King. The wider market moved on Wednesday as well, when Kansas City and Seattle completed the six player Maikel Garcia trade, a reminder that clubs are not waiting for the Skubal decision to improve.
For now, the honest summary is narrow and significant. Six clubs got meetings. The sourced expectation, from people involved in the negotiations, is a two team finish between the Mets and the Blue Jays. Toronto’s meeting went well, the money is real, the deadline is December 1, and the decision is expected sooner rather than later, even if one MLB.com update cautioned that it is not necessarily imminent this weekend. Until Skubal signs, nothing is done. But for the first time in this race, Toronto is not chasing the favourite. By the reporting of the insiders closest to it, Toronto is one of the two clubs the favourite has to beat.








